This guide started out as an index into my summaries of Katou Motohiro's manga, Q.E.D., along with mentions of the various physics and math elements used to underpin the stories. Unfortunately, the Japanese government, under pressure from the manga publishers, started enforcing copyright protection more strictly around 2019, and rather than take chances, I stopped providing sample scans of the artwork and character designs, as well as providing the chapter summaries. That's why the below lists stop at Q.E.D. iff volume 9.
Volume 01 (Minerva's Owl; Gold Pupil)
Volume 02 (Rokubu's Treasure; Lost Royale)
Volume 03 (Breakthrough; Faded Star Map)
Volume 04 (1st,April,1999; Jacob's Staircase)
Volume 05 (Twisted Melody; Light Afterimage)
Volume 06 (My Memories; The Blue Locked Room)
Volume 07 (Serial John Doe; Gloomy Afternoon)
Volume 08 (Falling Down; The Great School Festival Disaster)
Volume 09 (Rules of the Game; Frozen Hammer)
Volume 10 (In the Hand of the Witch)
Volume 11 (A Sea to Depend On; Winter Zoo)
Volume 12 (In the Corner of the Galaxy; Rainbow Mirror)
Volume 13 (Calamity Man; The Klein Tower)
Volume 14 (Summer Vacation Incident; Irregular Bound)
Volume 15 (Glass Room; Dedekind Cut)
Volume 16 (Cherry Blossoms; Cherry Blossoms; Dead Tears)
Volume 17 (Calamity Man's Worst; Black Nightshade)
Volume 18 (Arrival of the Famous Detective(s)!; The 3 Birds)
Volume 19 (The Ghost of Macbeth; The Sage's Bequest)
Volume 20 (Infinite Moon; The Busy Ms. Enari)
Volume 21 (Joined Threads; The Beautiful Actress being Watched, the Fear of the Stalker, the Gunshot Reverberating from the Cliff Face, What Touma and Kana Saw)
Volume 22 (Summer Stream; Venetian Maze)
Volume 23 (Liar; Another World)
Volume 24 (Christmas Eve Eve; Crime and Punishment)
Volume 25 (The Great UFO War; Parallel)
Volume 26 (Summer Time Capsule; Accomplice)
Volume 27 (Mirror Image; Juror Duty)
Volume 28(The Pharaoh's Neck Ornament; Human Fireworks)
Volume 29(Elephant; Motive and Alibi)
Volume 30 (The Mannequin Murders; Dog Dish)
Volume 31 (The Devil in Your Eye; Promise)
Volume 32 (Magic and Magic; Red File)
Volume 33 (The Paradox Room; The Detective Novelist Murder Case)
Volume 34 (Calamity Man Gets Married; Mother Shrine)
Volume 35 (The 2 Suspects; Christmas Present)
Volume 36 (Kurogane Mansion Murder Case; Q and A)
Volume 37 (A Lecture in Murder; Anime)
Volume 38 (Empty Dream; 17)
Volume 39 (The Incident in Aabanhiruzu Apts., Room 6; Grand Tour)
Volume 40 (Love Square; Locked Room #4)
Volume 41 (Special Envoy for Balkia; Caff's Recollections)
Volume 42 (Escher Hotel; The Tower of Logic)
Volume 43 (Verification; Ginger the Salesman)
Volume 44 (The Tuba and the Grave; Question!)
Volume 45 (Venus; First Love)
Volume 46 (Lost Love; Pilgrimage)
Volume 47 (The Sun is Still High Up; Hill Road)
Volume 48 (Literary Agent, Fayha's Book of Paintings)
Volume 49 (Unrelated Incident, Love Story)
Volume 50 (Observation, Escape Game)
- Start of the second season: iff -
Volume 01 (iff, In the year of Quantum Mechanics)
Volume 02 (The Naked Emperor, Shape of a Killer)
Volume 03 (The Three Assassins, Bike Thief)
Volume 04 (The Green Priestess, Handle Name)
Volume 05 (Even, The Imperfect Sealed Room Mystery)
Volume 06 (The Man Who Fell to Earth, Sudden Change)
Volume 07 (The Rainbow Over Ramanujan, The Showman)
Volume 08 (The Seashore Eye Witness, The White Crow)
Volume 09 (Spirit Fire, The Beautiful Painting)
Characters:
Sou Toma:
Yuu Touma:
Mr. and Mrs. Touma:
In volume 12, we learn that Sou's father is an architect and his mother is a historian. They love traveling around the world visiting archeological sites, and therefore aren't home much (we see them a little in "Liar" in volume 23, but they don't make their first real appearance in the manga until Q.E.D. iff vol. 3). Both parents are Japanese, but Sou and Yuu were both born in the U.S., so at age 18 they'll be expected to pick either Japanese or U.S. citizenship. The only other relatives we know about are their daughter, Yuu, and a cousin that is only hinted at in "Liar". In volume 28, we're told that Sou's mother's younger aunt has a son named Shinra Sakaki (hero of the C.M.B. series).
Kana Mizuhara:
Detective Koutarou Mizuhara and Mrs. Mizuhara:
Det. Sasaduka (and other detectives):
Loki (Sid Green) and Eva Sukta:
Annie Craner:
Alan Brad and Elly Francis:
The Mystery Club:
Kikuno Tanabata:
Science:
- Volume 1: Gold Pupil - The use of a Leyden jar to store static electricity charge.
- Volume 2: Rokubu's Treasure - Aspirin as a blood thinner.
- Volume 2: Lost Royale - History of the Bugatti Royale car.
- Volume 3: Faded Star Map - Discussion of star viewing. Mentions of Tycho Brahe, Johannes Kepler and Edwin Hubble. Description of the Gregorian Reflector-style telescope.
- Volume 4: 1st,April,1999 - Magnetism, magnets and monopoles.
- Volume 4: Jacob's Staircase - Conway's Game of Life, and how software firewalls and viruses work.
- Volume 5: Twisted Melody - Description of cellos made by Domenico Montagnana, Bach's "Suites for Unaccompanied Cello" and Kodaly's "Sonata for Solo Cello".
- Volume 5: Light Afterimage - Pinhole cameras, Ernst Leitz and the operations of the vintage Leica camera.
- Volume 7: Serial John Doe - Discussions of e, i, pi and -1. Mentions of Leonhard Euler, John Napier and Carl Gauss.
- Volume 9: Frozen Hammer - Discussion of the Bridges of Konigsberg problem and topology. Mention of Leonhard Euler.
- Volume 12: In the Corner of the Galaxy - Mention of Jack Williamson's Jonbar Hinge concept from the short story "Jon Barr".
- Volume 13: The Klein Tower - The story revolves around a specific kind of 3 or 4 story tower that can be found in Japan that is shaped like a corkscrew (Sazae-tou). Touma refers to this shape as a Klein bottle.
- Volume 15: Glass Room - Discussions of vacuum tubes, analog versus digital sound and gramophones.
- Volume 15: Dedekind Cut - Discussion of the Dedekind Cut, early AI research, Big Blue and chess, and a mention of Evariste Galois.
- Volume 16: Dead Tears - The properties of light at the boundaries of different surfaces.
- Volume 18: Arrival of the Famous Detective(s)! - Light reflects off glass doors.
- Volume 20: Infinite Moon - Discussion of infinity, and Georg Cantor's idea of aleph-null.
- Volume 23: Another World - The entire chapter is an explanation of the Riemann Hypothesis, with a little discussion of the 1974 Aricibo data transmission.
- Volume 25: Parallel - A simple overview of string theory, and a mention of the possibility supported by the theory of parallel worlds.
- Volume 26: The Pharaoh's Neck Ornament - Shinra from C.M.B. inspects an ancient Egyptian necklace on a dig near Cairo.
- Volume 29: Elephant - A discussion on Poincare's Conjecture, and an overview of topology.
- Volume 31: The Devil in Your Eye - Fraud performed by science researchers, and a mention of Hideyo Noguchi.
- Volume 32: Magic and Magic - Discussion of the magic book written by Professor Hoffmann.
- Volume 32: Red File - Discussions of financial markets, hedge funds and futures trading.
- Volume 33: The Detective Novelist Murder Case - Brief discussion of how mathematicians deal with paradoxes that show up in proofs.
- Volume 36: Kurogane Mansion Murder Case - Discussions of the strong and weak forces, and the possible existence of gravitons.
- Volume 38: 17 - During the Edo period (1600's to 1850's), certain people across Japan dabbled in the early development of differential calculus as an intellectual pastime, called "wasan" (Japanese algebra). However, rather than finding practical real-world applications for it, wasan masters would paint their problems and solutions on votive boards ("sangaku") to be donated to shinto shrines. This chapter discusses wasan, sangaku and the potential independent discovery of the math concept of "i".
- Volume 39: Grand Tour - No real science, per se, but the story revolves around a group of scientists that worked on the Voyager I and II satellites during the early 1970's, and the chapter has a number of really nice space drawings, plus a discussion on slingshot orbits.
- Volume 42: Escher Hotel - An examination of the artwork by M.C. Escher, and examples of attempts to recreate certain illusions in real life.
- Volume 42: The Tower of Logic - A discussion of logic puzzles, and how mathematic logicians develop and verify various proofs.
- Volume 44: Question! - A fairly comprehensive review of the history of the discovery of Fermat's Last Theorem. The entire chapter involves the various approaches that led up to Andrew Wile's complete solution.
- Volume 45: Venus - The story revolves around an astronomy textbook primer about the Sun and the inner planets. The science involves a description of how the Sun works, and a possibility of how the moon and Earth formed.
- Volume 45: First Love - No real science, just a look at a donkey rider logic puzzle by famed puzzle maker Sam Loyd.
- Volume 46: Lost Love - The solution is given for the donkey rider puzzle.
- Volume 47: The Sun is Still High Up - A discussion of the Traveling Salesman Problem, and attempts to solve the NP vs P problem.
- Volume 50: Observation - Touma talks about the search for dark matter using CCD sensors at the Cern Large Hadron Collider and the Keck telescopes in Mauna Kea, Hawai'i, and the neutrino detector at Kamiokande.
- Volume 01: In the Year of Quantum Mechanics - Part of the story is set in the 1920's, when Heisenberg and Max Born were arguing with Einstein over the then-new concepts of quantum particles, which prompted Einstein to say that "God does not play dice with the universe". There's a bit of quantum theory, and a short discussion about the people on both sides of the debate.
- Volume 02: Shape of a Killer - This is a locked room murder mystery set in the "Geometry Hotel" in Malta. There's a bit of discussion about pretzel problems and squaring the square.
- Volume 04: The Green Priestess - Discussion of the Lotka-Volterra (Predator/Prey) equations.
- Volume 04: Handle Name - Descriptions of how DoS and DDoS attacks work, and what LEET is.
- Volume 05: The Man Who Fell to Earth - Discussion of the Casimir effect and how it can be used with wormholes to allow for one-way time travel.
- Volume 07: The Rainbow Over Ramanujan - A brief history of India's famed mathematician, Ramanujan, and discussions of Riemann's zeta function.
- Volume 08: The White Crow - Just a passing mention of how to prove all crows are black.
21 comments:
Hello!
First of all, I'm also a Q.E.D and C.M.B fan so I like your blog, it's great! ^_^
but it seems they have stopped translating it in english....
So I was wondering, could you please maybe translate it? (either Q.E.D or C.M.B, as you want)
If you could just send me some translation notes I could incorporate them into the scans so that everyone can have the opportunity to read it
Could you?
Here is the link for the already translated chapters:
http://bato.to/read/_/25496/qed-shoumei-shuuryou_v1_ch1.1_by_orionwave (Q.E.D)
http://bato.to/read/_/25496/qed-shoumei-shuuryou_v1_ch1.1_by_orionwave
(C.M.B)
:)
Hi Fez, thanks for dropping by. I'd like to help, but at the moment my schedule is packed. If I get any free time, I'll see what I can do
All right, thanks a lot!
here's my e-mail just in case:
highschooldetective@yahoo.fr
I already have the RAW scans
have a good day!
arigatô ^^
Hi! Nice to meet you!
I just read the comment and yes, please,, I really want to read it english too, and i really hope that you can help..
I've been searching for the english translation whole time but couldnt find it too..
So please, I'll really appreciate for your kindness :)
Thank you so much!
Arigato gozaimasu!! :)
Hi! I'm a fan of Q.E.D and C.M.B too! nice to meet you :)
Your blog really help me.. but, I want ask you something..
Does the end of Q.E.D is in volume 50?
Because, I see in Motohiro-sensei's facebook page, in Magazine R there is new season of Q.E.D called Q.E.D iff. What's that mean?
link : https://m.facebook.com/pages/Manga-Perspective-by-Japanese-Professionals/310150279053383
Hi Nada, thanks for dropping by. Magajin R is a brand new magazine, and Q.E.D. is moving over to run there. I think that IFF is both a name change to mark this move, and a shift in direction for how Touma solves crimes. The first IFF is 96 pages long (half the length of one novel), and starts up with Kana and some friends talking about starting their last year in high school. They had been looking forward to getting money from a sculpture artist to help buy a new building for their kendo club, but the artist is murdered and the money is put on hold. Kana convinces Touma to help her father solve the crime. He agrees, but she's the one that has to do all the footwork interviewing the suspects, while Touma moves from his penthouse apartment to a new house (because the weight of all his books was threatening to collapse the floor). This time, rather than using his trademarked "Q.E.D." reasoning, Touma solves the crime with "if and only if (iff)".
For the most part, there's no major differences between Q.E.D. and Q.E.D. iff.
oh, I see.. Thanks a lot for the explanations :)
You're welcome, Nada.
I did see your previous comment before it was deleted. Have you tried contacting the Kinokuniya Bookstore in San Francisco? They do accept special orders for specific books, but you have to allow 3-6 weeks for the books to be shipped to the U.S.
No, I haven't.. hahaha.. It's in Japanese, right? I can't read it, then..
Oh, and also, actually I'm in Indonesia.. So, the shipping maybe takes longer time and more expensive
Hi hi! I just by chance found your blog and I am so happy!!! Thank you so much for putting so much effort in these reviews. Though we don't have scanlations but this is still great! I have loved this manga since ages :)
All the best to you!
do you think Touma is actually smarter than Shinichi Kudo ?
Hi Fez,
This kind of argument depends on who is writing the story. Generally, the creator of the character wants his character to be the smarter one. However, Kudo usually runs around everywhere looking for clues to the tricks used, and he needs a moment of inspiration to figure out what happened. Touma, on the other hand, wants to know the killer's motive. Once he has that, he figures out the trick very easily. Because of this, Touma is probably smarter than Kudo.
I see, thanks for your answer
so Kudo is like Sherlock while Touma is like Poirot, right ? ^^
Yes, like that.
can I get a link to read all those volume above
Unknown - If you just want the volume summaries, scroll to the top of the page and click on the volume number. Sorry, I don't do scanillations or full translations, though.
I'm so happy I found this blog, and that it's still active, it's a tragedy discussion of QED and CMB is very empty in the west.
A shame I can only read the scanlations but it'll make me very happy to read your thoughts on the volumes you reviewed once they get translated.
Stay well!
Halo!
Terima kasih sudah membuat deskripsi tentang karya-karya Motohiro Katou.
Aku adalah pembaca yang baru mengenali Q.E.D dan C.M.B. Awalnya aku mencoba membaca Q.E.D Shoumei Shuuryou dan ya aku langsung suka. Kesalahanku adalah membaca Q.E.D Iff saat Q.E.D Shoumei Shuuryou belum kutuntaskan, hanya kubaca beberapa chapter, dan tentu saja awalnya aku bingung karena melewatkan banyak hal. Aku menyelesaikan Q.E.D Iff hingga chapter terakhir saat itu lantas kembali membaca Q.E.D Shoumei Shuuryou. Dan kuputuskan membaca secara acak chapter manapun yang menarik diriku.
Ehm, aku benar-benar awam saat itu sehingga melakukan kesalahan yang cukup fatal. Tapi tak mengapa, aku berusaha belajar dari pengalaman yang kudapatkan.
Dan ya, sebab itu aku membaca C.M.B dengan berurutan, tak ingin kehilangan kejutannya.
Cukup dengan curhatanku, kini 12 Agustus 2021, dirujuk dari komentar terakhir di bab tentang Q.E.D ini, hampir 3 tahun sudah berlalu. Bagaimana kabarmu penulis? Kapan melanjutkan tulisan tentang Q.E.D Iff? Terakhir kali kulihat, sudah mencapai volume 18. Kuharap kamu dalam keadaan baik dan bisa meluangkan waktumu memperbaharui blogmu.
Oh iya, C.M.B sudah di volume terakhirnya, tapi aku belum menamatkannya. Aku tidak perlu terburu-buru untuk berpisah dengan Shinra, Nanase, dkk :)
Tetap semangat dan sampai nanti!
Hello Serena. Thank you for your email. I'm glad you like C.M.B. and Q.E.D.
Unfortunately, I live in Japan, and the government has passed strict laws to stop manga piracy. I don't know how these laws affect my summaries, but I want to be careful. So, right now, the Q.E.D. iff summaries are on hold.
Terima kasih sudah membalas, penulis. Akhirnya rasa penasaranku terjawab. Tidak apa-apa, kamu ingin lebih berhati-hati.
Jaga kesehatan di sana :)
Post a Comment